Meta PixelAnnual Audit Report 2024 — City of Tanjay — Page 101

Page 101 of 111

Page 101
                                                                                                Status of
 Ref                Observation                          Recommendations                   Implementation/
                                                                                          Results of Validation
No. 5,   to terms disadvantageous to the            observations, submit the loan          the loan agreement,
page     City, did not report the initial           agreement together with the BSP       BSP Monetary Board
 40      drawdown of ₱11,923,106.67 in              Monetary Board Opinion and             Opinion and BLGF-
         the Statement of Comparison of             BLGF-DOF certifications and             DOF certifications
         Budget and Actual Amounts                  also a certified true copy of SP       on Net Debt Service
         (SCBAA), did not maintain a                RN 18-196 bearing the signatures            Ceiling and
         special account for the loans to           of all concurring SP members on       Borrowing Capacity.
         monitor proper utilization thereof,        all pages, conduct a thorough              A letter for the
         contracted longer payment terms            assessment of the necessity of          justification on the
         beyond the term of incumbent               borrowing funds to avoid                  necessity of the
         officials and was not fully                additional interest and costs, with   procurement of heavy
         supported with the requisite               primordial consideration of the          equipment dated
         certifications and documents to            City’s ability to repay the loan          10/20/2021 was
         justify the necessity of contracting       within the incumbency of the                 submitted.
         the said amount.                           officials’ 3-year term in office,          The loans are
                                                    renegotiate on a fixed interest       monitored through a
                                                    rate, adjust the SCBAA, and             Subsidiary Ledger
                                                    direct the Accountant to maintain      with account no. 2-
                                                    a special account in the GF for        01-02-040 under the
                                                    loans secured.                         account title: Loans
                                                                                          Payable – Domestic.
2019     The City did not properly monitor      The City Mayor to:
AAR,     the implementation of eight
 AO      projects costing ₱43,144,693.82        76) Exercise the remedies provided          Unimplemented
No. 7,   which were found upon ocular               under Section 8.4, Annex “E” of        No action taken by
page     inspection to be either defective or       the Revised IRR of R.A. No.              management.
 46      with negative slippage nor did it          9184 in addressing the contracts
         take any of the courses of action          under default, without prejudice
         provided under Section 8.4 of              to other courses of action and
         Annex “E” of the 2016 Revised              remedies available under the
         IRR of R.A. No. 9184 against               circumstances;
         erring contractors, thereby causing
         unnecessary delay in the delivery      77) Require the City Engineer, CPDO         Unimplemented
         of the desired benefits by the             and other officials to submit a        No action taken by
         targeted end-users of the said             written explanation why no               management.
         projects.                                  immediate steps were undertaken
                                                    to address the deficiencies noted,
                                                    for the seeming lack of initiative
                                                    to enforce the measures available
                                                    to the government to correct such
                                                    defects, why progress payments
                                                    were allowed for projects with
                                                    negative slippage, and why final
                                                    payment was approved for
                                                    projects not compliant with
                                                    specifications; and

                                                78) Justify the obvious tendency of         Unimplemented
                                                    implementing        projects    by     No action taken by
                                                    contract given the additional            management.
                                                    indirect cost incurred and why the
                                                    same should not be regarded as
                                                    unnecessary expenses which are



                                                                                                                94