Meta Pixel SC voids councilor's win for filing candidacy while a party-list nominee | Kuryente News
news

SC voids councilor's win for filing candidacy while a party-list nominee

The Supreme Court denied with finality Cirilo Cordovilla Basalo, Jr.'s motion, declared his candidacy void ab initio, and annulled his proclamation as councilor.

SC voids councilor's win for filing candidacy while a party-list nominee
Image: Kuryente News

The Supreme Court denied with finality the Motion for Reconsideration of Cirilo Cordovilla Basalo, Jr. (Basalo), affirming the cancellation of his Certificate of Candidacy for municipal councilor after he simultaneously accepted a nomination as a party-list nominee in the same election. The Court declared his Certificate of Candidacy void ab initio and annulled his proclamation as Member of the Sangguniang Bayan of Montevista, Davao de Oro.

The Case

On October 4, 2024, Basalo filed a Certificate of Candidacy for the position of municipal councilor of the Sangguniang Bayan of Montevista, Davao de Oro in the May 2025 National and Local Elections. His name was later included in the Certified List of Candidates for Municipal Councilors.

Basalo claimed he subsequently learned of his nomination as the Second Nominee of the AKO TANOD party-list. Relying on Section 33 of COMELEC Resolution No. 11045, which prohibited the simultaneous filing of two certificates of candidacy but did not expressly prohibit the simultaneous filing of a certificate of candidacy and a certificate of acceptance of nomination, Basalo accepted his nomination.

In a December 16, 2024 Minute Resolution No. 24-1033, the COMELEC En Banc, in the exercise of its administrative function, cancelled both Basalo's Certificate of Candidacy for municipal councilor and his Certificate of Nomination and Acceptance as Second Nominee for AKO TANOD. The COMELEC En Banc ruled that a party-list nominee is prohibited from filing a certificate of candidacy for any elective office in the same election pursuant to Section 8 of Republic Act No. 7941 and Sections 8 and 14 of its Resolution No. 11045.

On December 27, 2024, Basalo filed his Statement of Withdrawal of Acceptance of Nomination and a Verified Motion for Reconsideration, which the COMELEC En Banc denied on January 3, 2025. The Commission ruled he remained ineligible because he had only until October 8, 2024 to cancel either his nomination or his Certificate of Candidacy. Basalo then filed a Special Civil Action for Certiorari under Rule 65, which this Court dismissed in an April 2, 2025 Resolution. His name remained on the Official Ballot, he garnered the fourth highest number of votes, and he was proclaimed a Member of the Sangguniang Bayan on May 14, 2025.

The Issue

Whether the COMELEC committed grave abuse of discretion in cancelling Basalo's Certificate of Candidacy, and whether his acceptance of a party-list nomination while filing a candidacy for an elective position violated the prohibition under the law.

The Ruling

The Court held that petitioner violated the prohibition and that the respondent's action was not attended by grave abuse of discretion. In its dispositive portion, the Court ruled:

"ACCORDINGLY, the Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED WITH FINALITY. The Minute Resolutions dated December 16, 2024 and January 3, 2025 of the Commission on Elections in M.R. No. 24-1033 are AFFIRMED. Petitioner Cirilo Cordovilla Basalo, Jr.'s Certificate of Candidacy for municipal councilor in the May 12, 2025 National and Local Elections is DECLARED VOID AB INITIO. Petitioner's proclamation as Municipal Councilor is ANNULLED and SET ASIDE."

The Court directed the COMELEC to constitute a Special Municipal Board of Canvassers to recanvass the valid votes for municipal councilor, exclusive of those cast for petitioner, and to proclaim the duly-elected Municipal Councilor. The Resolution was declared immediately executory, with no further pleadings allowed and entry of judgment to be issued immediately.

By the Numbers

  • October 4, 2024 — Basalo filed his Certificate of Candidacy for municipal councilor
  • September 27, 2024 — date he accepted his party-list nomination
  • October 8, 2024 — deadline to cancel either his nomination or candidacy
  • December 16, 2024 and January 3, 2025 — COMELEC Minute Resolutions
  • April 2, 2025 — Resolution dismissing the Petition for Certiorari
  • May 14, 2025 — Basalo proclaimed as Member of the Sangguniang Bayan
  • Fourth highest number of votes — his standing in the election
  • G.R. No. 278469

The Court's Reasoning

The Court found that petitioner's defense of good faith was belied by several circumstances, which it said were indicative of bad faith. His sworn Certificate of Acceptance of Nomination contained a statement that he was "not a candidate for any elective office" in connection with the May 12, 2025 elections, making it perplexing that he claimed ignorance of the prohibition stated in the very certification he voluntarily signed.

The Court also noted a contradiction: while petitioner stated he only learned of his nomination after filing his Certificate of Candidacy, his Certificate of Acceptance of Nomination showed he accepted the nomination on September 27, 2024 — before he filed his candidacy on October 4, 2024.

Citing Abayon v. House of Electoral Tribunal, the Court observed that party-list representatives are elected into office, not their parties, and a party-list is represented through its nominee who personally assumes the seat. Sustaining petitioner's interpretation would allow nominees to be elected to two posts based only on a superficial distinction, undermining the law's intent to prevent one elective official from representing different constituencies.

The Court held that a cancelled Certificate of Candidacy is void ab initio and cannot give rise to a valid candidacy, and that invoking the sovereign will of the electorate cannot cure a candidate's ineligibility. Thus, the proclamation predicated upon a void candidacy had to be annulled.

Source: Supreme Court Resolution in G.R. No. 278469.

This report summarizes a public Supreme Court decision and is not legal advice.

Watch Kuryente News on YouTube Subscribe

Get the week's top stories in your inbox

Free weekly newsletter — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.