The Supreme Court has dismissed for lack of merit a complaint accusing two Public Attorney's Office (PAO) lawyers of gross ignorance of the law and ethical violations for representing a client before the appellate courts. The Court found no fault in the actions of respondents Atty. Flordeliza G. Merelos and Atty. Geoanne Christi D. Battad.
The Case
The complaint was filed by Leonora O. Miaral against Atty. Merelos and Atty. Battad, who are lawyers of the Public Attorney's Office (PAO). Miaral is the respondent in G.R. No. 217777, titled "Priscilla Z. Orbe v. Leonora O. Miaral." In that case, Atty. Merelos and Atty. Battad filed a petition for review on certiorari questioning the decision of the Court of Appeals (CA) ordering the withdrawal of the Information for estafa against Miaral.
Miaral objected to Atty. Merelos and Atty. Battad representing Priscilla Z. Orbe, her sister-in-law. According to Miaral, Priscilla is gaining from her business and is not a pauper litigant, allegedly owns a big house in a subdivision, is a majority stockholder of a travel company, and owns a motor vehicle. Given these, Miaral contended that the PAO lawyers should not have taken Priscilla as a client.
Miaral also imputed gross ignorance of the law, arguing that only the Office of the Solicitor General (OSG), not the PAO, is authorized to represent the government in criminal cases before the CA and the Supreme Court. Finally, she faulted Atty. Battad for failing to indicate her Mandatory Continuing Legal Education (MCLE) number when signing the petition.
The same Complaint had also been filed before the Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) Commission on Bar Discipline (IBP-CBD). In a Resolution dated March 13, 2017, the Court referred the Sworn Complaint to the Department of Justice (DOJ), considering that the acts imputed were related to the respondents' functions as PAO lawyers. The Court later enjoined the IBP from proceeding with the complaint. In its Compliance dated May 23, 2022, the DOJ stated that based on the findings made by the PAO, Priscilla qualified as an indigent and may properly be represented by the PAO.
The Issue
The Court framed the issues as: whether the respondents are guilty of gross ignorance of the law and violations of the Code of Professional Responsibility and Accountability (CPRA) for representing Priscilla; whether Atty. Battad is guilty of gross ignorance of the law for failing to indicate her MCLE number; and, between the PAO and the OSG, which agency should handle appeals in criminal cases involving the government.
The Ruling
The Court held that the complainant is wrong. While the authority to represent the government in criminal cases before appellate courts is exclusively lodged with the OSG, the Court stressed that Orbe is not criminal in nature. It ruled that respondents, in representing Priscilla, did not violate any rule or arrogate upon themselves the authority which properly belongs to the OSG.
The dispositive portion reads: "ACCORDINGLY, the Complaint against respondents Atty. Flordeliza G. Merelos and Atty. Geoanne Christi D. Battad is DISMISSED for lack of merit."
By the Numbers
- A.C. No. 11571 — the administrative case number of this decision.
- G.R. No. 217777 — the case titled "Priscilla Z. Orbe v. Leonora O. Miaral."
- Criminal Case No. Q-12-174206 — the underlying pending criminal case titled "People of the Philippines v. Leonora O. Miaral."
- March 13, 2017 — Resolution referring the Sworn Complaint to the DOJ.
- December 29, 2017 — Manifestation with Motion filed by respondents.
- June 13, 2018 — IBP Comment interposing no objection.
- September 10, 2018 — Resolution enjoining the IBP from proceeding.
- November 29, 2021 — Resolution noting the DOJ's failure to submit its recommendation.
- May 23, 2022 — DOJ Compliance endorsing the matter to the PAO.
- 30 days — non-extendible period for the OSG to file comment under the guidelines.
The Court's Reasoning
The Court explained that a criminal case is primarily concerned with the punishment of a wrong, where the parties to the action are the People of the Philippines and the accused, with the offended party regarded merely as a witness for the state. In Orbe, the petition for review filed by respondents on behalf of Priscilla was aimed not to establish the penalty of complainant in the underlying pending criminal case, but to challenge the withdrawal of information ordered by the CA.
The Court noted that in criminal cases, the participation of the State as the offended party is indicated by including "People of the Philippines" in the caption. This detail was not present in Orbe, which is captioned as "Priscilla Z. Orbe v. Leonora O. Miaral." The Court concluded that Orbe is merely a procedural offshoot of the pending criminal case against complainant, and that respondents did not violate any rule or arrogate upon themselves authority belonging to the OSG.
The Court also referred to guidelines on the legal standing of private complainants in assailing judgments or orders in criminal proceedings, which provide that the private complainant has the legal personality to appeal the civil liability of the accused or file a petition for certiorari to preserve his or her interest in the civil aspect of the criminal case.
Source: Supreme Court decision in A.C. No. 11571, penned by Associate Justice Hernando.
This report summarizes a public Supreme Court decision and is not legal advice.
