Meta PixelAnnual Audit Report 2024 — Province of Negros Oriental — Page 72

Page 72 of 161

Page 72
11.1   CSC Resolution No. 021480, dated November 12, 2002, was circularized
       through Memorandum Circular No. 24, S. 2002, to provide clarificatory policy
       guidelines on contracts of service, ensuring the proper implementation of CSC
       Memorandum Circular No. 2017, S. 2002.

11.2   As defined under Section 1.a. of the CSC Resolution 021480, a Contract of
       Service (COS) refers to the engagement of a person, private firm, non-
       governmental agency, or international organization to perform specific work or
       tasks requiring special or technical skills not available within the agency.

11.3   In CY 2024, the Provincial Government entered into various contracts of service
       with private individuals to work as Force Multipliers for data acquisition under
       Task Force SAGAR and Task Force Octopus. Each contract generally covers a
       six-month period, with a monthly compensation of ₱5,000.00.

11.4   A review of the subsidiary ledgers revealed that, as of September 30, 2024, the
       Provincial Government incurred a total expenditure of P16,595,000.00 for the
       payment of services rendered by 709 Force Multipliers. These payments were
       charged against the appropriations for Support to Task Force Octopus classified
       as Other Maintenance and Operating Expenses.

11.5   Post-audit of the report of disbursements (RDs) related to these payments
       disclosed the following observations:

The contract lacks specific duties, functions, and definite expected outputs.

11.6   Section 517 of the GAAM, Volume 1, states that agencies may enter into
       contracts with individuals or organizations, both public and private, subject to
       the applicable laws and guidelines approved by the President. These contracts
       must be for specific services that cannot be provided by the agency’s regular
       staff, must be for a defined period, and must have clearly stated expected output.

11.7   A review of the contracts revealed that the hired individuals, referred to as focal
       persons, agreed to work for the Province as Force Multipliers in data acquisition
       for Task Force SAGAR and Task Force Octopus.

11.8   Task Force SAGAR and Task Force Octopus is an inter-agency task force aimed
       at addressing criminality, peace, and security matters. They are composed of
       eight units- intelligence, anti-illegal drugs, criminality, anti-insurgency, anti-
       illegal gambling, terrorism, disaster response and anti-cybercrime.

11.9   However, the contract did not specify their duties and functions, as well as the
       expected output to be delivered within the period covered by the contract.
       Without clear performance indicators and standards, Management had no basis
       to measure the actual services rendered and to assess whether their contributions
       aligned with the achievement of the desired outcomes.




                                                                                       66