Meta PixelAnnual Audit Report 2024 — Municipality of Valencia — Page 56

Page 56 of 118

Page 56
  5.14. As for the time deposit with PVB, it was confirmed to have originated from a transfer
        of funds previously held with FCB. This deposit was likewise originally designated
        as a hold-out for employee loans.

  5.15. Regarding the LBP time deposits, an inquiry with the Municipal Treasurer’s Office
        revealed that no supporting resolutions or authorization could be located, either by
        the Municipality or the bank. The accounts in question were reportedly opened more
        than 10 years ago. The Treasurer’s Office, however, asserted that LBP would not
        have opened such accounts without proper authorization from the Municipality at the
        time.

  5.16. Due to the lack of submitted documents, the purpose of the time deposit placement
        could not be fully verified.

  5.17. We recommended that Management:

      5.17.1 Cease the placement of funds in time deposits unless properly supported
             by a detailed computation showing excess funds beyond the
             Municipality’s normal operating and financial requirements, in
             accordance with Sections 21 and 22 of COA Circular No. 92-382; and

      5.17.2 Instruct the Municipal Treasurer to retrieve and submit complete
             supporting documents for all existing time deposit accounts, particularly
             those under LBP, to validate the legality and appropriateness of such
             investments.

   5.18. The Municipal Treasurer mentioned that despite their efforts to locate the necessary
         documents, they could only submit those related to bank accounts opened during his
         term, as the other accounts were opened by the previous Municipal Treasurer. He
         added that the deposits earn the Municipality substantial interest income due to
         higher interest rates compared to a regular savings account. He further explained
         that they considered these funds idle, as they are under protest and remain
         unutilized pending resolution. Nevertheless, he agreed to comply with the
         termination of the time deposits and the transfer of these to regular savings accounts
         once they mature.

Delinquent RPT and SET

6. Delinquent Real Property Taxes (RPT) and Special Education Taxes (SET)
   including penalties accruing thereon which accumulated to ₱18,374,734.90
   remained uncollected as of December 31, 2024, depriving the Municipality of
   substantial amount of income which could have been utilized to finance the
   implementation    of    various development  projects   or other     major
   programs/projects/activities (PPAs).




                                                                                            48