Meta PixelAnnual Audit Report 2024 — Municipality of Valencia — Page 50

Page 50 of 118

Page 50
     the name of taxpayers and the amount due and collectible for the year. Based
     on the list, the Chief Accountant shall draw a Journal Entry Voucher (JEV) to
     record the debit to Real Property Tax Receivable/Special Education Tax Receivable
     and crediting to Deferred Real Property Tax Income/Deferred Special Education
     Tax Income.” (Emphasis supplied.)

3.5. However, records showed that in CY 2024, the Municipality’s RPT and SET
     receivables, each amounting to ₱53,232,192.80, were established only in November
     2024, covered by JEV Nos. 100-2024-11-6285-Z-18 and 200-2024-11-632-E. The
     Municipal Accountant explained that, despite her request at the beginning of the
     year, the Municipal Treasurer did not furnish her with a duly certified list showing
     the names of the taxpayers and the amounts due and collectible for the year.

3.6. It may be mentioned that collections for CY 2024 RPT and SET Receivables started
     in January 2024. Hence, credits to both receivable accounts representing collections
     were recorded even though the corresponding receivables have not yet been
     established.

3.7. Furthermore, we noted that the assessment roll from the Municipal Assessor was
     submitted to the Municipal Treasurer only on November 12, 2024. A personnel
     from the Municipal Assessor’s Office explained that they were unaware of the
     requirement for the Municipal Assessor to prepare and submit the assessment roll to
     the Municipal Treasurer on or before December 31 of each year. They assumed that
     submission was unnecessary since the Municipal Treasurer had access to their iTax
     System, a taxation software acquired by the Municipality from a private service
     provider.

3.8. Although the RPT and SET Receivables were set up on November 12, 2024, these
     accounts should have been established at the beginning of the year in accordance
     with Section 20 of the NGAS Manual. Establishing them late in the year, after
     collections had already been made, would affect the accuracy of the receivable
     balances as of December 31, 2024, since collections from January to November
     were recorded without corresponding receivables being in place. The year-end
     balances may include distortions or mismatches in reported deferred income and
     receivable accounts. This timing discrepancy results in unreliable and potentially
     misstated receivable figures in the financial statements.

3.9. We recommended that Management coordinate with the iTax System
     Technician to determine whether the amounts of RPT and SET Receivables
     established in November 2024, based on the assessment roll received by the
     Municipal Treasurer on November 12, 2024, would have been the same had
     the assessment roll been generated and made on or before December 31, 2023.

3.10. We further recommended that the Municipal Accountant prepare the
      necessary adjusting entries, if warranted.



                                                                                      42