Meta PixelAnnual Audit Report 2024 — Municipality of Sibulan — Page 79

Page 79 of 122

Page 79
     12.4 An inquiry with the Municipal Accountant revealed that the balance had been
          overlooked and had not yet been remitted to the National Treasury, even after the
          lifting of the State of Public Health Emergency. However, the Municipal
          Accountant assured that he would coordinate with the Municipal Treasurer to
          prepare a check payable to the National Government, ensuring that the balance
          would be promptly remitted to the National Treasury.

     12.5 The Municipality's inability to remit the unutilized funds to the National Treasury
          deprived the National Government of the opportunity to use these funds for
          priority projects, programs, and activities.

     12.6 We recommended and the Municipal Accountant agreed to provide the
          Municipal Treasurer with the records of unutilized funds under the BGCM
          so that the latter can return these funds to the National Treasury in
          accordance with Item 3.9 of DBM LBC No. 125 dated April 7, 2020.

     12.7 The Municipal Accountant and Municipal Treasurer disclosed that a disbursement
          voucher has already been prepared to return the unutilized funds to the National
          Treasury.

Fund Transfers not supported by MOA and Approved Project Expenditures or Expenses

 13. Fund transfers amounting to ₱420,000.00 provided to the Barangays of the
     Municipality as subsidy for Sibul Festival were not supported by the Memorandum
     of Agreement (MOA) and Approved Project Expenditures or Expenses as required
     under COA Circular 2012-001 dated June 14, 2012, resulting in a lack of
     accountability, insufficient oversight and challenges in monitoring and liquidation.

    13.1   Item 3.1.1 of COA Circular No. 2012-01 dated June 14, 2012, as amended by COA
           Circular 2016-002 dated May 31, 2016, enumerated the following documentary
           requirements for fund transfers:

             1.   Copy of MOA/Trust Agreement
             2.   Copy of Approved Program of Work (for infrastructure project)
             3.   Approved Project Expenditures or Estimated Expenses indicating the
                  project objective and expected output (for other projects)
             4.   Certification by the Accountant that funds previously transferred to the
                  Implementing Agency (IA) have been liquidated and accounted for in the
                  books
             5.   Copy of the OR issued by the IA to the Source Agency acknowledging
                  receipt of funds transferred

    13.2   During our post-audit of Disbursement Vouchers (DVs) (Annex A), it was
           revealed that the Municipality transferred a total of ₱420,000.00 in subsidies to its
           Barangays. These funds were intended to cover expenses related to the Pagsibul
           sa Kabataan and Pagsibul sa Barangay Festival. The subsidies were sourced from
           the Municipality's General Fund under the Culture and Arts Development
           Program.


                                                                                             62